These pumpkin pie bars have a buttery brown butter shortbread crust, creamy spiced pumpkin filling and a generous swirl of toasted brown sugar meringue. All the cozy flavor of pumpkin pie, but SO MUCH BETTER!
If I’m being completely honest, I’ve always liked a simple pumpkin pie but I was never impressed by it. Like it’s good but when there are so many desserts to choose from, pumpkin pie isn’t at the top of the list…at least not in the traditional sense.
In fact, I think it’s kind of boringggg lol.
HOWEVER, I have two favorite things that are not boring – brown butter shortbread and meringue. After I put meringue on my traditional pumpkin pie, there was no looking back. Trust me on this one, it is far superior to whipped cream – the textures are just made for each other and the toasted exterior *chef’s kiss*.
Ingredient Notes & Substitutions
The full recipe is in the recipe card at the bottom.
Milk: most pumpkin pie recipes use either evaporated milk or sweetened condensed milk or even cream. I used milk because I wanted to keep this simple and more pantry-friendly. Dairy-free milk also works but I would not substitute it for cream or evaporated milk because I haven’t tested those.
Pumpkin: I use Libby’s pumpkin puree. 365 brand also works well but I haven’t tried other brands. Make sure it’s NOT pumpkin pie filling, just pumpkin puree.
Butter: I recommend salted European-style butter for the shortbread crust. If not, then at least use salted butter instead of unsalted, it browns better.
Sugar: I used light brown sugar in the crust, filling and meringue but this can be subbed for either dark brown sugar, granulated sugar or a combination of the two. Do not reduce the sugar, especially in the meringue or it will weep.
Spices: I made my own pumpkin pie spice in the recipe but you can sub it for 1 ½ tablespoons of store-bought pumpkin pie spice.
The Details
Crust: the same brown butter shortbread that I’m obsessed with from my pecan pie bars and my lemon bars!
Filling: a simple pumpkin filling with pantry staples.
Meringue: I made a brown sugar meringue and torched the outside – SO GOOD!
Brown Butter Shortbread
If you’re not familiar with brown butter, it’s easier than you think. If you absolutely want to skip it, you can, but make sure to use the reduced amount of butter listed in the recipe, not the starting amount, since you lose a little butter during browning.
Brown the butter – melt the butter in a pan, stirring intermittently until it begins to foam. Then stir continuously while it’s browning.
Pour into a bowl and let it cool for a few minutes.
Mix in the sugar and cinnamon until they’re well combined.
Add the flour and mix until there are no more streaks.
Press into the pan and bake just halfway, until lightly golden. The crust should be partially baked before adding the filling so it has enough structure to hold the pumpkin layer without getting soggy.
Note: If your brown butter is still hot when you make the crust, it will be much more runny, not spread able and dough like. That’s totally fine, it will still bake up the same.
brown butter mixed with brown sugar, vanilla & cinnamon for the shortbreadFlour mixed into dough, finished shortbread doughshortbread pressed into pan (if your butter was still hot, this will be much more runny, that’s fine too)shortbread halfway baked, ready for filling
Pumpkin Filling
Whisk together the sugar, eggs, pumpkin, flour and spices until they’re well combined.
Add in the milk and whisk enough to make sure the filling is not gloopy from the eggs.
Pour over the par-baked crust and bake until the edges are set and the center is still a bit jiggly.
Cool completely and then refrigerate for several hours before slicing – preferably overnight.
batter for the fillingpour on top of par-baked crust
Whisk sugar, cream of tartar and egg whites over a double boiler.
The sugar has to be fully dissolved, and the mixture should reach 170°F (77°C) before whipping.
Whip the egg whites and sugar into a fluffy meringue – this may take 5-10 minutes.
Use meringue to frost the top of the bars and toast it using a culinary torch. I sliced my bars before torching so I could toast all sides of the meringue dollop on each slice.
Marshmallowy Swiss meringue
Serving & Storing
These do need to be refrigerated, especially to slice cleanly, but they can stay out for a couple of hours after slicing.
For clean slices, use a sharp knife and wipe it clean between cuts. I like slicing them cold straight from the fridge.
If the meringue is made right (enough sugar and heated to the correct temperature) it should be stable enough to endure refrigeration or freezing.
I would store these in the fridge for up to 3-4 days and freeze for any longer.
Thank you so much for being here. If you love this recipe, please leave me a 5-star rating or a review.
1 1/2tspcinnamon, OR replace all spices with 1 Tbsp pumpkin pie spice
1/2tspginger
1/2tspnutmeg
1/2tspcloves
120mLwhole milk
pinchsea salt
Brown Sugar Meringue
3largeegg whites
1/4 tspcream of tartar
150gramslight brown sugar
2tspvanilla bean paste
tinypinchof fine sea salt
Method
Brown Butter
If the butter is cold, cut it into cubes and place it into a light colored, medium size saucepan, over medium-low heat.
227 grams salted butter brown to 186 grams
Use a wooden spoon or rubber spatula to stir the butter occasionally. It will begin to bubble, continue stirring intermittently.
Once it begins to foam, you won’t be able to see what’s happening so stir continuously, making sure to scrape the solids off the bottom of the pan. The milk solids will begin to settle on the bottom of the pan and darken in color.
Remove from the heat and continue stirring for another minute or so, until the butter darkens into an amber color.
Pour the butter, with all the little solid bits, into a heat safe jar and allow it to cool.
Shortbread
Preheat the oven to 325F (163C) and grease and line an 8×8 baking pan with baking spray and parchment paper. *see note on baking pans.
Measure out the brown butter and allow it to cool for a few minutes before using.
186 grams browned butter melted
Add in the brown sugar, vanilla and cinnamon and mix until they're well combined.
Fold in the flour, just until the last streak of flour is mixed in, and press into the prepared pan. *if the butter was still hot, the dough will be more wet, this is fine, it still bakes up the same.
240 grams all-purpose flour spooned and leveled
Bake for about 20 minutes, just until the edges are starting to brown. Remove from the oven and allow to cool while you prepare the filling.
Pumpkin Filling
In a medium bowl, whisk together the sugar, eggs, pumpkin, vanilla, flour and spices until they're well combined.
100 grams light brown sugar, 2 large eggs, 200 grams pumpkin puree, 2 tsp vanilla bean paste, 1 1/2 tsp cinnamon OR replace all spices with 1 Tbsp pumpkin pie spice, 1/2 tsp ginger, 1/2 tsp nutmeg, 1/2 tsp cloves, pinch sea salt, 15 grams all-purpose flour
Add in the milk and whisk until it's fully combined. Pour the mixture over the par-baked crust. Light tap the pan on the counter to release any air bubbles.
120 mL whole milk
Bake for another 25 minutes or so. You want the edges set and slightly puffed, but the center a little bit jiggly – it will continue baking and set as it cools.
Allow to cool for a little and then refrigerate for several hours before slicing. I like to slice it before adding the meringue so it's less messy.
Meringue
Bring a small pot with a little water to a boil and then reduce the heat to simmer (keep it on very low heat). Wipe down your equipment with a tiny bit of vinegar or lemon juice (any edible acid) and then place the sugar and cream of tartar in the bowl of a stand mixer, whisking them together.
150 grams light brown sugar, 1/4 tsp cream of tartar
Add the egg whites to the bowl and whisk the egg whites into the sugar. Place the bowl of egg whites and sugar on top of the simmering water (making sure it doesn’t submerge into the water) – you want the steam to heat the egg whites.
3 large egg whites
Whisk the egg whites frequently so they don’t coagulate around the edge of the bowl. Generally around 5 minutes, the sugar will feel like it’s dissolved in the egg whites but you want to take the egg whites to 175F (80C) in order to get that stable, marshmallowy texture, which is normally around 10 minutes for me. So make sure to check the temperature with a thermometer between the 5-10 minutes (it may take up to 15 minutes).
Once it’s at 175F (80C), turn the stove off, remove the bowl from the simmering pot and place it on the stand mixer fit with the whisk attachment. Beat at medium speed for a minute and then increase to medium-high for about 10 minutes.
Add in the vanilla extract and salt and mix, that just until it’s combined, making sure to scrape the edge of the bowl as well. The texture should be thick and marshmallow – not dry.
2 tsp vanilla bean paste, tiny pinch of fine sea salt
Use a spoon or a piping bag to frost the bars and use the culinary torch to toast the meringue.
Notes
Store fully covered in the refrigerator or freezer, serve cold or slightly chilled. Dust fresh with powdered sugar. *I recommend using a glass or ceramic pan so the lemon doesn’t react with metal. But if you only have metal, make sure it’s coated with non-stick, not scratched (or put through a dishwasher) and double line it with parchment paper so the filling doesn’t touch the pan at all.